 |
| From L-R: David Cook, Kris Allen, Lee Dewyze, Scotty McCreery and the newly crowned Phillip Phillips |
I'll be honest, I stopped watching AI the moment Taylor Hicks took crown in Season 5. Such a letdown, especially following the amazingly talented, beautiful and down-to-earth Season 4 victor, Carrie Underwood. Still, I kept with the times, reading the news and occasionally chancing upon it on TV.
It was one of these "occasional chances" that made me decide to watch AI again. It was top 8 or 9ish by then and I heard Jessica Sanchez sing. Holy smokes, I thought. This is it. She wasn't perfect. Her renditions of Queen's "Bohemian Rhapsody" and Aerosmith's "I Don't Wanna Miss A Thing" were okay at best (Steve Tyler was being nice). Her stage presence needed work, unlike Joshua, Skylar and Phillip, who were naturals. But she had raw talent, she was young, passionate and more importantly she was marketable.
Online, the signs pointed to her victory (let's forget the whole "Saved" debacle, which was totally staged anyway). Check out this infographic I made summarizing Jessica and Phillip's respective social media profiles before the finale:
It's clear that Jessica has a larger, or at least more socially active, following. So why did Phillips win?
It's a simple answer that many businesses tend to overlook. As important as social media is, it does not necessarily represent offline behaviour. First, a handful of Jessica's fans are likely non-Americans. Second, just because someone shares his or her opinion online, doesn't mean it will translate to concrete actions.
I wish I didn't have to say I was disappointed with the results. After all, Phillip Phillips is a very talented man in his own right (and hot to boot). Still, with AI's ratings steadily dropping since Season 6, a fresh new winner might have been just the boost it needed.
Til then,
Mae
No comments:
Post a Comment